Wednesday, 29 June 2016

Ataturk Explosion Reports: A Couple of Questions.
I always find the source video of these 'terrorist events' very interesting and often instructive as to whom (at least) was first on scene, for which prior knowledge was probably necessary. For just one recent similar example see: . Virtually never are the sources of these images pursued, or the question asked how they came to be taken.
Also when witness reports appear to conflict with others it raises questions that are seldom answered or brushed aside. The visual images that always appear to immediately find their way onto the internet (and equally those that don't!) can provide useful markers in the direction of who knew and who planned the attack.
In the case of the Ataturk Airport bombing the video of the reaction to the explosion shown by the BBC here (  appears to come from 'Haber Turk HD'. See: and from which I quote this extract:
"From the day that it starts to broadcast, maintaining the principle of honest, true, fast and objective newscasting Habertürk Television has taken place among the leader companies in media in a short time and in 2009, it became “The Most Watched News Channel in Turkey”.

Being the leader of internet news reporting in Turkey, has been selected as the most loved news internet site and proved once more that it is the “Biggest Online Newspaper in Turkey” by  Ipsos KMG Digital Lovemark survey. continues to draw attention by means of the innovations and developments in the media sector."

Haber Turk appears to be part of the Ciner Group, a large industrial conglomerate probably little known in the West, except in specialist circles . It dates from relatively small beginnings in the 1980's importing Mercedes spare parts, to its position today with multiple interests and companies, including comparatively recently in its Haber Turk newspapers and TV linked to the American media company Bloomberg. See: and and (Note the latter Bloomberg source for the latter)
Because Ciner is a 'Private Company', detailed information on the group and its composite companies is hard to come by, particularly who controls and funds it. The following description of its activities comes from the latter source.

Company Overview

Ciner Group, through its subsidiaries, operates in energy, mining, media, commerce, industry, and service businesses in Turkey. The company’s Ciner Energy and Mining group engages in the operation of thermal power plants; production of coal from the underground coalmine; production of soda ash and sodium bicarbonate; extraction of copper ore, and production and export of copper concentrate; production and marketing of electrical energy; and wholesale, import, export, and direct sale of electrical energy. Its Ciner Media group is involved in the publishing of a national newspaper; printing, distribution, import, and export of various types of periodicals, such as newspapers, magazines, books, brochures, and other similar works; shooting, recording, copying, sale, purchase, distribution, marketing, and renting of movie pictures, TV serials, video clips, advertisement and commercial films, and television programs; operation of a television channel, a radio channel, and an Internet news broadcasting site; and operation a Turkish language real-time financial news and business television channel. The company’s Ciner Commerce, Industry, and Service group engages in the provision of flight transportation services through a fleet of business jets; operation of a clinic that provides healthcare services to group employees and the local public; tourism, air cargo transportation, rent-a-car, and auto park management activities; operation of hotels; operation of a port that provides loading and unloading services to vessels; warehousing, highway and sea transportation, and trade businesses; insurance agency and textile businesses; production of glass packaging products and silica sand; operation of bulk carrier and tanker vessels; provision of ship management services; and organization of seminars and similar events. Ciner Group was formerly known as Park Group and changed its name to Ciner Group in January 2005. The company was founded in 1978 and is based in Istanbul, Turkey

Its prime mover and principal controller appears to be one, Turgay Ve Madencilik Anonim Sirketi CINER who is Chairman of the Board and President who is claimed to have a personal wealth of more than a billion pounds. 
It would appear as of 2.11.2015, power of attorney was granted by him in the United States for a company called 'OCI Resources' LPSee:
In fact from it appears that the Atlanta contacts are far more extensive: 

People related to Ciner Turgay, company Ciner Resources LP

Akkan Enerji ve Madencilik Anonim SirketiATLANTAGA
Ciner Enterprises Inc.ATLANTAGA
Daniel Nicole C.ATLANTAGA
Jasper Thomas WNEW YORKNY
Milling Kirk H.ATLANTAGA
O'Neill William P. Jr.ATLANTAGA
OCI Co Ltd.SEOULKorea, Republic of
OCI Enterprises Inc.ATLANTAGA
OCI Wyoming Holding Co.ATLANTAGA

From "Ciner Resources Corporation, formerly OCI Chemical Corporation, was purchased by Park Holding A.S., a subsidiary of Ciner Group of Istanbul, Turkey on October 23, 2015. OCI Enterprises will continue to own and operate the Sodium Percarbonate (SPC) business, OCI Alabama LLC in the U.S. under a new entity called OCI Peroxygens LLC."
From     "July 20, 2015 09:00 AM Eastern Daylight Time
ATLANTA--()--OCI Enterprises Inc., the North American subsidiary of OCI Company Ltd. (“OCI”) of Seoul, Korea, has signed a definitive agreement to sell its approximately 73% limited partner interest in OCI Resources LP (NYSE: OCIR) (“OCI Resources” or the “Partnership”), as well as its 2% general partner interest and related incentive distribution rights, to Park Holding A.S., a subsidiary of Ciner Group of Istanbul, Turkey.
OCI Resources owns a controlling interest comprised of a 51% membership interest in OCI Wyoming LLC (“OCI Wyoming”), one of the largest and lowest-cost producers of natural soda ash in the world. Ciner Group, through its subsidiary, Eti Soda, operates a natural soda ash production facility in the world's second largest trona ore bed located in Beypazarri, Turkey.
It is hard to determine the significance of the following (translated) abstract from: but what could the title, "Turgay Ciner under the control of parallel organizations" or "had become the center of the most disgusting guardianship of black propaganda" possibly mean?
"Rasim Ozan Kütahyalı

Turgay Ciner under the control of parallel organizations

12 Subat 2014

"Yesterday in writing by Turgay Ciner files and tapes from the judgment that I wrote caged by parallel organizations. Cinema was so scared of this structure, especially in the 2011-12 season, going constantly Pennsylvania " At your service" , he said. This parallel organization also bluntly telling the media actors. This was not a situation stored.Fethullah Gulen followers in the speech of the fact that the situation is obviously pickup.Ciner, censor the author of his own newspaper Smiling name. He says forbidden to write against Gülen. 
Disciple: We've been Mr. Turgay Ciner today. He had a corner writing negative state of the author. We learned it. We searched for him. Personally launched. "This newspaper, nothing will stand against you," he said. All these 'Service Organization, "he said. "Our elder (Gülen) against the I make something here." 
Fethullah Gulen: Very good. Thank God."

"Parallel organization Turgay Ciner next Fatih Altayli of the files in its possession and had cages with tape. After the Haberturk newspaper and TV February 7 had become the center of the most disgusting guardianship of black propaganda. Especially frightened file Altai in terrible shape in the hands of the organization. Our scamp Conqueror had become toys in the hands of the organization. Still in that case . On the other hand, in the 2011-12 season through the judicial files and blackmail tapes Ciner Media takeover parallel organization conducted the operation against the AKP was not idle. Move towards the end of 2012 passed and made ​​some moves. After February 7 beyond AKP that all elements of the state apparatus in a position against Cinerama Republic of Turkey conveyed to him. State Cinema who fear the enemy position felt a need to balance the situation. Fatih Saraç'ao so he gave that task."

"Ciner eyyamc broadcast in 2013 and hypocritical policy of the ruling. But the group did not change the actual weight in practice. Currently, parallel power was dominated by the Cinerama. Saddler was standing right there as Yalova Governor. Much more organized parallel organization, the AKP, a power also was ambushed and successful. The trap they Here currency infamous scandalous results of the last few days wandering in the media.Since the AKP's early strategy for Cinerama was wrong and now It exploded in their hands. Sabah as at that time we also far from the Ciner group, we continued to stop construction because this group was an extension of the old Turkey as guardianship mentality. One group was given the SHOW TV. Complete this was ignominy. As I said at that time the AKP's senior to those who always wanted me to do this criticism continued to criticism hard to write it, and I told him what I knew. Now he is hitting the stone heads names. Ciner Group has created a perception as well as the control of both the parallel organization if AKP held in your hand. AKP because they gave ground."

"Currently the Ciner Media is establishing parallel organizations through a nasty trap of civil politics. Parallel organization continues to shoot birds with one stone. Fatih Altayli and parallel organization publishes many people's voice recordings by assembling itself .So now both Cinerama parallel organization of an illegal operation is in tatters with all men. But nobody criticize the Cinerama out parallel organization of a single word.Because they are afraid they will remove the tape from the other. The parallel organizations for fear that they are attacking the Prime Minister Erdogan wants. As Altay is infamous enough that only by adopting a style of parallel structures now come loaded to the AKP. Installed as the biggest mistakes that I have no objection expressed AKP. But y ayınlan be contrary to the law of the tape could not escape the attention of Altai one word spread parallel police and prosecutors on the internet. He entered the order of the rape cases currently Altay. Everyone makes a note of it. Pathetic. 
We opened new Turgay Ciner file. We will continue tomorrow."

From "Muhammed Fethullah Gülen (born 27 April 1941) is a Turkish preacher,[5]former imam,[5][6] writer,[7] and political figure.[8] He is the founder of the Gülen movement (known as Hizmet meaning service in Turkish). He currently lives in self-imposed exile in the United States, residing in Saylorsburg,Pennsylvania.[9][10][11] Gülen was an ally of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan before 2013. The alliance was destroyed after alleged 2013 corruption investigations in Turkey.[16][17][18][19][20] Erdogan accused Gülen for being behind the corruption investigations.[21] He is currently on Turkey's most-wanted terrorist list and is accused of leading what the current Turkish officials call the Gulenist Terror Organisation (FETO).[22][23] A Turkish criminal court issued an arrest warrant for Gülen.[24][25] Turkey is demanding the extradition of Gülen from the United States.[17][26][27]However, so far there is no Turkish court decision that charges Gulen or his followers with any terrorist activity.[28][29][30]"

Some obviously believe this gentleman, though very dangerous, has the active support of 
US Secret Services. From 
we have this:

"Exclusive: World’s ‘Most Dangerous Islamist’ Alive, Well, and Living in Pennsylvania
Paul Williams, PhD
April 7, 2010

An Islamic Armed Fortress Emerges in the Pocono Mountains

The most dangerous Islamist in the world is neither Afghani nor Arab.
He comes from neither Sudan nor Somalia.

And he resides in neither the mountains of Pakistan nor the deserts of the Palestinian territories.

This individual has toppled the secular government of Turkey and established madrassahs throughout the world.

His schools indoctrinate children in the tenets of radical Islam and prepare adolescents for the Islamization of the world.

More than 90 of these madrassahs have been established as charter schools throughout the United States. They are funded by American taxpayers.

One of these charter schools – Tarek ibn Zayed Academy (TiZA) in Minnesota – is so radically Islamic and subversive in nature that the Minnesota Department of Education issued two citations against it and the American Civil Liberties Union is suing it.

Dozens of his universities, including the Faith University in Istabul, train young men to become lawyers, accountants, and political leaders so that they can take an active part in the restoration of the Ottoman Empire and the Islamization of the Western World.

He also allegedly operates compounds to train jihadis in the tactics of guerilla warfare.
This individual has amasssed a fortune – over $30 billion – for the creation of a universal caliphate.

His name is Fethullah Gulen and he resides not in the wilds of southern Turkey – but the mountains of Northeastern Pennsylvania.

From his fortess headquarters, located on 28 acres at 1857 Mt. Eaton Road in Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania, Gulen plots the overthrow of secular governments and oversees the spread of education jihad throughout Asia, Europe, and the United States."

Is it worth noting that the US security services have a strong presence in Atlanta. From ... comes the following: 

"The United States Secret Service, which upholds a mission of being both an investigative and protective federal law enforcement agency, has a strong presence in Georgia, thanks to the three field offices located here:
  • Albany 229-430-8442
  • Atlanta 404-331-6111
  • Savannah 912-652-4401
The Secret Service also has two task forces in place in Georgia, both of which operate out of the Atlanta field office:
  • Electronic Crimes Task Force: Designed to investigate any number of electronic crimes that could result in terrorist attacks against infrastructure and financial payment systems
  • Financial Crimes Task Force: Designed to investigate financial crimes that threaten the nation’s financial payment systems and critical infrastructure
Training – All candidates for Secret Service agent jobs should also be prepared to undergo an extensive course of training following their hire. The first training period takes place at the Federal Law Enforcement Agency Training Center (FLETC) in Georgia for a period of 11 weeks, while the second training period takes place at the James J. Rowley Training Center in Washington D.C. for a period of 16 weeks. The inability to complete either training program results in an individual’s separation from the Secret Service."

The BBC quoted a US source who called the attack "heinous", saying America remained "steadfast in our support for Turkey" whilst Russian President Vladimir Putin, with whom recent relations have been strained,  offered his condolences to Turkey.

So to repeat, perhaps "Haber Turk HD" would like to explain how it happened to be where it was just as terrified people ran from the airport or indeed why given that one witness states two explosions happened outside (which conflicts with the graphic which states TWO were inside and one out) Will Carter states, "I was in the baggage area when there were TWO large explosions outside and then there was a third explosion inside the building" ( Yet in the same post there is this plan that clearly shows the opposite. Notice also the sequencing which appears to be the reverse of what Will Carter described!

Graphic of attack


  1. The links run deep and obscure to the general public. See: "Among the documents that the state attorneys presented, there are claims about the Gülen movement's financial structure and it was emphasized that the movement's economic power reached $25 billion. "Schools, newspapers, universities, unions, television channels . . . The relationship among these are being debated. There is no transparency in their work," claimed the attorneys. They continued, "Gülen's own statements indicate that he is a religious man who spreads his philosophy through education; however, he is not an educator."

    The main points appear to be that Gülen is not an educator. As a matter of fact, he has no education at all. More interestingly, it would appear that Gülen receives money from the CIA. The names of the 26 persons who wrote reference letters for Gülen's petition are given at the end of the Milliyet article. Since there's some suspicion on the part of the DHS as to CIA funding of the Fethullahcı, then there's a very high possibility that the 26 persons listed by Milliyet have received CIA funds through Gülen.

    Let's note right now, too, that the most interesting of those 26 persons are the first three: George Fidas, Graham Fuller, and Morton Abramowitz.

    George Fidas worked at the CIA for thirty-one years. Nowadays, he likes to write about the effects of global infectious diseases on US national security. He probably knows all about the AIDS virus that was created by the US government in a little lab outside of New Orleans. Frighteningly enough, the guy also teaches international relations at Washington University.

    Graham Fuller is another ex-spook who was deeply involved in Afghanistan in the 1980s, encouraged the Reagan administration to begin arming Iran against Iraq during their slugfest, and suggested to the Clinton administration that it use Muslims to further US interests in Central Asia. Fuller also seems to have gone "native" on the Islam thing, as he's written a number of articles and books on political Islam. He's also written of his love affair with that most high-profile of Gülen's gangs, the AKP, and he's co-authored a book on Turkish Kurds with Henri J. Barkey, Turkey's Kurdish Question. It's always nice to know that something is a shameless piece of propaganda, which is exactly what Turkey's Kurdish Question is.

    On a more ominous note, Graham Fuller was listed as one of the American Deep State rogues on Sibel Edmonds' State Secrets Privilege Gallery, and if Sibel's nailed him, the dude's guilty.

    Just to cement the idea that Turkey's Kurdish Question is a piece of anti-Kurd propaganda, the third person on Milliyet's list of those who wrote reference letters for Gülen is Morton Abramowitz, who wrote the forward to Turkey's Kurdish Question for Barkey and Fuller. I guess he figures he's an expert, given that he was the US ambassador to Turkey from 1989 to 1991. But Abramowitz was also deeply involved with Afghan mujahedin and Kosovo rebels. And if you ever wondered about the colossal ineffectiveness of Human Rights Watch, well, it may be because scumbags like Abramowitz are affiliated with it."

  2. Compare this video from "Rutnet" with this video from Brussels, filmed by a Mossad asset here: Strangely similar?

    1. Is this it?

  3. Clearly some point the finger at Russia: "Kravasis Viriza3 hours ago
    Shut up, kremlins! All people can google "Yarovaya law". All people can see that Putin rules Russia for 16 years. People in Ryazan catched FSB when them were trying to put 250kg of RDX in basement or their house for provocation. It is well known fact!
    Putin bombs Russia first in 1999. FSB killed people. FSB destrioyed democracy in Russia. There were no free elections till 2002 year. It is well known!
    Russia was an country of authoritarianism. Now it is an country of terror and falsehood.
    Russian regular forces and paramilitary platoons stand on annexed parts of Ukraine. Russian artillery units shell Marioupol, Volnovakha, Donetsk, Avdijovka and many other points.
    Russians are in Syria, them do not secure their bases - them support Asad's army in field operations. Many of them are killed. FSB pressed on their families by terror.
    Russians want to control Syria - the Key to support the EU by oil and gas. Them want to control sea deposits of gas. Russians bring death and terror everywhere!"

  4. In reply to Andrew G Johnston here:
    Well that's one way of looking at it but I'm not sure the 'left/right' paradigm works any more. Just look at the last twenty years - Blair aping Thatcher, Cameron aping Blair. Indeed although politicians live by disagreement, there is little blue (or red) water between them, all realising that their survival depends on securing the middle ground, where most of the populace resides. They all reside on a 'greasy pole' of their own career, fulfilling the useful role of deflecting attention from the real shakers and movers who remain in virtual anonymity, which is where they like to be. Just as 'left' and 'right' are largely illusionary, so those companies and individuals with interests and agendas are very real. Never forget the circumstances of 9/11 and 7/7 and the intentional lies that were told to the British people to pursue an essentially zionist agenda in the middle east. The facts, however mollified by Chilcot, are now too convincing to ignore, even though MSM will not touch it and Government actively resists it. It proves to me at least, there are indeed dark forces at work, particularly in the western world, intent on destabilisation and conflict, not in the interests of the people, but of its own selfish agenda. It is this that we should focus our attention on, not the largely ficticious and fabricated division between 'left' and 'right', or even 'in' and 'out'.

  5. A coincidence too far? From 'Daily Pickings'
    "Coincidence? US State Department Renews Travel Warning Day Before Istanbul Attacks by Vanessa Beeley
    The US State Department spokesperson, Mark Toner, “partly, coincidentally” reissued the travel alert for Istanbul the day before the suicide bomb attacks in Istanbul’s Attaturk airport, that so far, have claimed 42 lives and left over 200 wounded. As Mark Toner waffles through his explanation, one could say he protests too much?"


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.